The Truth About MLM Compensation Plans Power Dynamics

The Anatomy of a Direct Sales Compensation Plan

Direct sales compensation plans, also known as multi-level marketing (MLM) or network marketing compensation plans, are the financial engines that drive these businesses. They are designed to reward individuals for selling products or services and for building and leading sales teams. While the specifics vary greatly from company to company, understanding the core components is crucial for anyone considering joining or already participating in a direct sales opportunity.

Common Types of Compensation Plans

Direct sales companies employ several popular compensation plan structures. Each has its own nuances in how it rewards distributors:

Unilevel Plan: This is perhaps the most straightforward plan. You can sponsor an unlimited number of people directly onto your "first level." Everyone they sponsor falls onto your second level, and so on, creating an unlimited depth of levels. Commissions are paid on sales made by distributors within a certain number of levels.
Binary Plan: In a binary plan, you can only place two people directly under you (in your "downline"). Any additional recruits are placed under one of your first two. This creates two legs or branches. Commissions are typically earned based on the sales volume of the weaker leg.
Matrix Plan: Matrix plans limit the width and depth of your downline. For example, a 3x5 matrix means you can have a maximum of three people directly under you, and commissions are paid down five levels. If you recruit more than three people, they "spill over" to others in your downline.
Stairstep Breakaway Plan: This is a more complex plan that combines elements of other structures. Distributors progress through ranks. When a distributor in a downline achieves a certain rank, they "break away" from their upline for commission purposes, meaning the upline no longer earns commissions on that breakaway's downline. However, the upline may receive "infinity bonuses" or override commissions on breakaway teams.

Understanding Breakage

Breakage is a critical concept in direct sales compensation plans, and it benefits the company. It refers to commissions that are not paid out to distributors. This can happen for several reasons:

Unqualified Distributors: If a distributor doesn't meet the minimum sales or recruitment requirements for a particular commission period, they won't earn commissions, and those potential payouts become breakage for the company.
Reaching the Cap: Some plans have caps on how much a distributor can earn from a particular bonus or level. Once the cap is reached, any further sales that would have generated income for that distributor become breakage.
Unpaid Commissions: In rare cases, due to administrative errors or system limitations, some commissions might not be accurately calculated or distributed, contributing to breakage.
Rollovers and Carryovers: In plans like the binary, if one leg has significantly more volume than the other, the excess volume from the stronger leg might roll over to the next commission period. This is not necessarily "lost" income but can be seen as a delay, and if distributors don't consistently generate volume, it can effectively become breakage over time.

Breakage is a legal and expected component of compensation plans. It helps companies manage their payout ratios and ensures profitability. A healthy breakage rate is typically between 5-15%, but this can vary. Significantly higher breakage rates could be a red flag.

Average Payouts and Income Disclosure

It's important to manage expectations regarding income in direct sales. Many direct sales companies publish an Income Disclosure Statement (IDS). This document, often required by law in many regions, shows the actual earnings of their distributors over a specific period. It typically reveals that:

A small percentage of distributors earn significant income.
A larger percentage earn modest amounts, often to cover expenses or for supplemental income.
A substantial portion of distributors earn very little or nothing at all.

The average payout percentage across the entire distributor base is often between 35-50% of the company's revenue. However, this average includes both top earners and those who don't earn much. Focusing on the potential to earn at different ranks and the effort required is more insightful than looking at a broad average.

What Keeps Direct Sales Compensation Plans Legal

The legality of direct sales compensation plans hinges on them being product-based and focused on retail sales to actual customers, rather than solely on recruitment. Key factors that ensure legality include:

Legitimate Product or Service: The company must offer a real product or service with genuine retail value.
Retail Sales Focus: The primary emphasis must be on selling products to end consumers who are not distributors. Commissions should be primarily earned from these retail sales.
No Required Inventory Purchases: While some initial product purchase might be necessary to start, distributors should not be required to buy excessive inventory to remain active or earn commissions.
Reasonable Training and Support: Legitimate companies provide training and support to help distributors sell products.
No Promises of Guaranteed Income: Companies cannot guarantee specific income levels, as earnings are dependent on sales effort and market conditions.
The "80/20 Rule" (Not a Strict Law but a Guideline): While not a universally codified law, many regulators look at whether at least 80% of sales are to actual retail customers outside of the distributor network.

Red Flags to Watch For

When evaluating a direct sales compensation plan, be vigilant for these warning signs:

Emphasis on Recruitment: If the primary way to earn money is by recruiting new distributors, rather than selling products, it's a major red flag, indicating a potential pyramid scheme.
High Upfront Investment: Requiring distributors to purchase large amounts of inventory or pay significant fees to join is suspicious.
Vague or Misleading Income Claims: If the company or its distributors make unrealistic promises about how much money you can earn with little effort, be cautious.
Lack of Retail Customer Base: If the vast majority of "customers" are actually distributors buying products to meet quotas, it's problematic.
Pressure to Buy: Being pressured to constantly buy more products to stay active or qualify for commissions can be a sign of a plan focused on internal consumption rather than external sales.
Complex and Opaque Plan: If the compensation plan is overly complicated and difficult to understand, it might be designed to obscure the true earning potential or lack thereof.

Solid Compensation Plan Characteristics

Conversely, a robust and legitimate direct sales compensation plan will exhibit these qualities:

Clear and Transparent: The plan is easy to understand, with clearly defined ranks, requirements, and commission structures.
Balanced Rewards: It rewards both product sales and team building, but with a clear emphasis on retail sales.
Reasonable Requirements: The requirements to earn commissions and advance in rank are achievable through consistent effort.
Retail Customer Focus: The company actively promotes and supports sales to genuine retail customers outside the distributor network.
Supportive Training and Tools: The company provides resources and training to help you succeed in selling products.
Realistic Income Disclosure: The Income Disclosure Statement reflects the reality of earnings potential, aligning with the effort required.

Due Diligence is Key

Asking questions about the compensation plan when presented with an opportunity is not just recommended; it's a necessity. Look for companies that reward you at a higher percentage for sales to retail customers than they do for recruiting. This indicates a genuine focus on product sales. Request a PDF of the compensation plan and ask for it to be explained step-by-step. If the person presenting the opportunity cannot adequately answer your questions, don't hesitate to ask to speak with someone who can.

Here are some good questions to ask about a compensation plan:

What is the breakdown of commission percentages for direct sales versus team recruitment?
How are retail customer sales rewarded compared to sales made by other distributors in my downline?
What are the specific requirements to earn commissions at each rank?
Are there any caps or limits on the commissions I can earn?
What is the average income earned by distributors at my level and at higher levels, according to your Income Disclosure Statement?
Can you provide me with a detailed copy of the compensation plan and walk me through an example of how I would earn income?
What are the monthly or periodic requirements to remain active and qualify for commissions?
How is "breakage" calculated, and what is the typical percentage of commissions that are not paid out?
What kind of training and support is available to help me achieve retail sales success?
The Potential for Lucrative Success

Direct sales can indeed be a highly lucrative path when all the right elements align. Imagine a scenario where a company offers
A product or service that is truly in demand, with minimal direct competition.
Couple this with a compensation model that generously rewards both the effort of building a customer base and the skill of recruiting and mentoring a team.
Crucially, add to this a robust system that empowers every distributor, regardless of experience, to learn, participate, and duplicate the strategies of successful leaders.

In such an environment, where the product is exceptional, the rewards are fair and motivating, and the support structure fosters growth and duplication, the potential for significant financial success and personal fulfillment in direct sales becomes remarkably high.

If you have questions about compensation plans CLICK HERE

Back to table of contents